Google Welcomes UK Regulator to Oversee the Depreciation of Cookies
Google has delayed the phase-out of third-party cookies until 2023 and has granted UK regulators full oversight of this transition amid industry backlash and competition complaints alleging that Google's move threatens the open web and strengthens its dominance by leveraging its extensive first-party data.
When Google announced it was sunsetting the cookie early last year, the ad industry went spiraling. Everybody, including us, has been talking about the announcement ever since.
Every time Google releases a new blog adding to the cookie saga, the industry goes a little crazy.
And now, the latest announcement is that Google is delaying its farewell to the cookie until 2023. Not only that, but it has given UK authorities full oversight of the transition.
Marketing Firms Weren’t Happy with Google
Third-party cookies allow advertisers to track user behavior across websites in order to deliver personalized advertising. Over the years, digital advertisers have become accustomed to a vast amount of data and the removal of cookies presents a real threat to how they operate.
Without cookies, digital advertisers will have a harder time tracking visitor behavior across other websites. But not only that, Google may become an even greater force in digital marketing (if that’s even imaginable).
Google has troves of first-party data collected via its search engine, Youtube, Gmail, and app downloads. Critics of Google’s decision to remove cookies argue that the decision was not an altruistic ‘privacy-first’ decision, but an effort to build up its moat.
Critic Brian Handrigan, chief executive of Advocado, put it this way: Google is a “wolf in sheep’s clothing” and its newfound love of privacy was a “land grab.”
So They Took Their Concerns to the UK Government
Though Google was developing solutions that enable advertisers to deliver relevant ads without individual identifiers under The Privacy Sandbox initiative, marketing firms continued resisting Google’s decision.
Last year a group of 20 marketing firms filed a competition complaint with the UK’s Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), saying that they “share a concern that Google is threatening the open web model that is vital to the functioning of a free and competitive media and online economy.”
Google Welcomed Feedback and Offered an Oversight Period
About three weeks ago, Google told the CMA and the public that it was committed to increased transparency, substantial limits on its use of Chrome data for advertising, and that it wouldn’t discriminate against rivals in favor of its own advertising products.
Google also volunteered the CMA a 60-day “standstill period” in which the watchdog could reopen investigations into any issues. And it delayed its cookie sunset by two years (including the six months of oversight period). The current plan is to start saying good-bye to cookies over a three month period starting mid-2023.
Though the CMA is taking the lead as the primary regulator, it will be asking for input from the broader web community during the six-month consultation period.
“The CMA is now asking others in the industry for feedback on these commitments as part of a public consultation, with a view to making them legally binding,” wrote Google legal director Oliver Bethell on the Google blog. “If the CMA accepts these commitments, we will apply them globally.”
For more updates like this, stay tuned. Subscribe to our blog for more updates on coronavirus and its mark on the economy.
Related
What’s the Latest with Cookie Alternatives?
With Google's planned phase-out of third-party cookies by late next year, the ad tech industry is rapidly developing and testing over 100 alternative identity and contextual solutions, with Unified ID 2.0—an open-source, privacy-focused technology supported by major advertising companies—gaining significant traction as a potential new standard, while platforms like Xandr emphasize flexibility by integrating multiple solutions to adapt to the evolving landscape.
Where Have All the Cookies Gone?
The article explains that with increasing restrictions on third-party cookies due to privacy concerns and regulations like GDPR and CCPA, brands must shift from relying on cookies for tracking and personalized advertising to building consumer trust through transparency about data collection and usage, as well as adopting new strategies to deliver personalized experiences without invasive data capture.
How are Advertisers Spending on Programmatic as Cookies Depreciate?
As third-party cookies phase out by 2023, advertisers are increasingly experimenting with new programmatic advertising solutions like Google's Privacy Sandbox and Unified ID 2.0, focusing on leveraging first-party data, cohort modeling, and contextual analysis to maintain effective targeted advertising and campaign measurement in a privacy-centric digital ecosystem.
Which New Advertisers are Using Programmatic?
Despite ongoing industry uncertainty from Google’s cookie replacement decision and increasing privacy restrictions, ad tech stocks like PubMatic and The Trade Desk are surging as new programmatic advertisers embrace opportunities in connected TV, identity solutions, and retail media, with leaders viewing these changes as beneficial for the open internet’s future.
Google the Cookie Monster: What their Latest Initiative Means to Ad Tech
Google announced its plan to phase out third-party cookies in Chrome by 2022 as part of its Privacy Sandbox initiative to enhance user privacy, collaborating with major tech companies through the W3C to reshape web advertising while facing criticism for limited publisher and marketer involvement.
Ad tech Companies Prepare for a World Without Cookies
Apple's introduction of App Tracking Transparency in iOS 14 requires apps to obtain user permission before tracking across other companies' apps and websites, significantly limiting targeted advertising by removing access to the Identifier for Advertisers (IDFA) and building on previous privacy measures like Intelligent Tracking Prevention, thereby forcing ad tech companies to adapt to a new landscape where most users likely opt out of tracking.