How are Advertisers Spending on Programmatic as Cookies Depreciate?
As third-party cookies phase out by 2023, advertisers are increasingly experimenting with new programmatic advertising solutions like Google's Privacy Sandbox and Unified ID 2.0, focusing on leveraging first-party data, cohort modeling, and contextual analysis to maintain effective targeted advertising and campaign measurement in a privacy-centric digital ecosystem.
The advertising industry faces an uncertain future with cookies and personal identifiers disappearing.
Though there are many alternate solutions in development, the two solutions gaining the most traction are Google’s Privacy Sandbox and the Unified ID 2.0.
Now that cookies won’t sunset until 2023, advertising professionals have time to experiment with these new pathways.
It’s time to experiment with new forms of data
The ad tech industry has been busy since Google announced it was removing third-party cookies from Chrome. The digital ecosystem relied on cookies to deliver relevant, targeted ads and to measure campaign effectiveness.
Without cookies, advertisers will have to rely on first-party data and find new ways to deliver effective digital ads programmatically.
“The next two years are critical and advertisers will need to research and experiment and most importantly really interrogate what is coming on to the market to replace third-party cookies,” said Clare O’Brien, head of media effectiveness and performance at ISBA, the trade body representing UK advertisers.
For many digital advertising professionals, this change requires a fresh look at what valuable content and marketing look like. Marketers will have to deliver highly valuable content for consumers to earn first-party data and they’ll have to start mastering different data models.
“Google’s cookie deprecation and Apple’s many privacy initiatives represent an opportunity for marketers to up their game on when it comes to their own cohort modeling and contextual analysis initiatives,” writes Andrew Frank, VP distinguished analyst at Gartner. “This can be done in addition to shoring up first-party data collection and consent management to gain a competitive edge.”
A marketer case study for Unified ID 2.0
Earlier this week a brand case study was (finally) released for the UID 2.0. Though ad tech companies and publishers have been experimenting with the new solution, brands have been slower to jump on board. Most are waiting for the industry to establish which tool will be the next standard.
“Marketers want to be early adopters, but not the guinea pigs,” explains James Hercher at AdExchanger. But one brand took the plunge.
Made In, an eCommerce cookware manufacturer, recently completed a streaming TV campaign running on UID 2.0. They saw a 20% decrease in its average cost per acquisition. On top of this, customer acquisition decreased by a third when using the identifier.
By taking the risk, Made In proved that they could deliver successful campaigns without cookies. With cookies depreciating, we’ll see more brands begin to adopt new solutions and publish their results.
Digital advertising isn’t going away. Brands, publishers and ad tech companies will need to adopt solutions that benefit everyone, while protecting the consumer’s privacy. As these companies go through major changes, are they shifting their digital spending?
MediaRadar Insights
Despite the changing ecosystem, programmatic advertising continues to increase year-over-year.
In 2021, over 279 thousand advertisers spent $21.3 billion in programmatic advertising (January – September). This is up 61% from 2020 where 189 thousand advertisers spent $14.7 billion.
Brands that benefited from the pandemic largely drove programmatic spending last year. This year, consumers are spending in new ways, causing a slight shift in the top spending categories.
The main difference is that Tech has become less dominant, while Entertainment brands have newly emerged as a top spending category. This is a reflection of the recovering economy.
Within the top 20,000 advertisers, the top spending categories in 2021 are: Retail, Finance/Real Estate and Entertainment. Last year at this time, the top categories were: Retail, Finance/Real Estate and Tech.
Advertisers that fall within the ‘Other’ category make up 18% of all spending—more than the clear-cut categories.
Top spending advertisers are:
- SmartNews Mobile App
- Walmart
- HBO Max
- Capital One Shopping
- Disney+
Their spend totals $711 million—which is an increase of 73% compared to last year. (This excludes SmartNews Mobile app because it is a new programmatic advertiser).
Just like last year, there are many new brands willing to experiment with programmatic. 63% of advertisers are new to the programmatic space. While we don’t know how long they’ll stay, we believe that digital advertising and programmatic buying will only grow in importance post-pandemic, even without cookies.
Related
Which New Advertisers are Using Programmatic?
Despite ongoing industry uncertainty from Google’s cookie replacement decision and increasing privacy restrictions, ad tech stocks like PubMatic and The Trade Desk are surging as new programmatic advertisers embrace opportunities in connected TV, identity solutions, and retail media, with leaders viewing these changes as beneficial for the open internet’s future.
Which Categories are Adjusting Programmatic Spend the Most in July?
In July 2020, despite a 14% year-over-year increase in overall programmatic ad spend, many brands—especially in the tech sector—are bringing programmatic buying in-house to gain better control over first-party data and budgets amid pandemic uncertainties, while digital publishers are seeing recovering CPMs after initial drops, with some like Salon reporting a 25% revenue increase compared to the previous year.
4 Surprising Brands That Aren’t Buying Programmatic Ads in 2021
In 2021, despite increasing programmatic ad spending overall driven by privacy-driven changes like Apple's ATT and Google's cookie alternatives, many top advertisers are shifting their strategies, with only 8 of the top 100 programmatic buyers from 2020 returning in 2021, reflecting a 38% year-over-year increase in spend but notable brand departures from programmatic advertising.
DTC Advertisers are Changing Up Their Programmatic Spend
In 2021, direct-to-consumer (DTC) brands are shifting their programmatic advertising strategies by increasingly managing marketing in-house to leverage first-party data and advanced technology for personalized multi-channel experiences, resulting in a 44% decrease in programmatic ad spend despite a rise in the number of advertisers, as iconic brands gain market share and eCommerce accelerates.
Signal & Noise Podcast
The Signal & Noise podcast, hosted by Rio Longacre and Brett House, features in-depth discussions with industry leaders on how technology, AI, data transparency, and innovation are transforming modern advertising, media quality, and publisher monetization, including episodes addressing challenges in news media, brand safety, and evolving streaming landscapes, highlighted by a special live series from Advertising Week 2025 with prominent experts.
The State of Retail Media: What to Know and Why Advertisers Are So Excited
Retail media networks are rapidly growing as advertisers invest over $3 billion since 2021 to leverage retailers' vast first-party shopper-level data—such as Amazon's 200 million Prime members—to deliver targeted ads amid the decline of third-party cookies and increasing privacy regulations, capitalizing on the U.S. retail market projected to reach $5.35 trillion by 2025.