How the Pandemic is Influencing Regional Advertising
The pandemic's impact on regional advertising varied significantly across states due to differing public policies, with stricter states like California and New York experiencing a sharper 49% drop in ad spending—especially in print—compared to 31% in Texas and Florida, and while real estate advertising rebounded quickly in CA and NY due to urban exodus, TX and FL saw a slower recovery influenced by housing supply constraints, whereas energy advertising overall declined 52% from 2019 levels and remains subdued despite recent modest improvements.
The pandemic has impacted the entire nation, but its influence greatly varies across state lines.
Those living in California had a different experience than those living in Texas. And those living in New York had a different experience than those in Florida.
Much of this has to do with public policy. Restrictions varied greatly among locations, leading to differences in regional ad sales.
Due to the variations, we analyzed pandemic regional trends from four states—California, Texas, Florida, and New York—to help you with your regional sales strategies.
Regional Advertising Trends
Overall our data shows that states with stricter policies, like California and New York, were more impacted by the loss of ad buying.
The large dip in Q2 2020 was felt across all regions and primarily in print publications. Ad spend in California and New York fell 49%. In Texas and Florida, it fell 31%. Overall, $450 million of ad spending was lost from Q1 2020 to Q2 2020.
Spend has not yet fully recovered to pre-pandemic levels, but there are key differences among categories.
Real Estate
Realtor advertising in CA and NY recovered immediately from the 39% drop between Q1 and Q2 2020. Advertising spend in Q3 2020 reached its high in CA and NY when people were looking to move out of large cities.
TX and FL dropped slightly more (42%) from Q1 – Q2 2020 and their recovery has been more gradual. It took three quarters to increase 28%. This is likely due to a case where demand outweighed supply. In July, Texas major metro areas reported less than a two-month supply of houses for sale.
Energy
Overall, local Energy advertising remains dim compared to 2019.
Advertiser spend peaked in 2019 at $1.8 million. It has since fallen 52%.
Year-over-year, the category is down 10% (January – June, 2021 vs 2021). Nationally, the category is flat year-over-year.
More recently, spending has been improving. It saw a 23% improvement over Q1 in 2021. On a national level, energy advertising between Q1 and Q2 2021 rose 102%.
It’s worth noting that ad spending is driven by renewable energy, which currently makes up 66% of the total category’s spend.
Restaurants and Bars
Texas and Florida were among the first states to lift in-person restrictions, which we see in the immediate return of spending (in Q2 2021). Spending in Texas and Florida grew 25% between Q1 and Q2 of 2021, and has almost recovered to pre-pandemic levels of Q2 2020 (-.1%).
However, we see a strong drop in the Q3 projected numbers. This is likely a result of the Delta variant resurgence. 60% of Americans have changed their restaurant habits due to the rise of the variant, impacting the industry at large.
Despite reopening, NY and CA are still down almost 50% from pre-pandemic levels.
With the Delta variant causing outbreaks again, the economy is experiencing a slowdown. However, economists predict that it will accelerate once again. Because we don’t know when this will be exactly, we’ll keep updating you with the most recent data to help inform your sales strategy.
Related
12 Ads ‘til New Year: 12 New Advertisers in 2020
In 2020, amid the COVID-19 pandemic's drastic shifts in consumer behavior, 411,000 brands spent $81.27 billion on advertising across media, with 5,500 new brands—particularly from direct-to-consumer companies, subscription boxes, and OTT services—emerging prominently to meet the demands of quarantined and socially distanced audiences, as highlighted in a year-end series spotlighting twelve notable new advertisers.
Car Buying Apps Are Changing the Auto Industry—But How Are They Advertising?
Car buying apps, which have surged in popularity especially among millennials who increasingly complete purchases online, are disrupting the traditional $840 billion used car market by purchasing inventory directly and offering a lower-pressure, digital-first buying experience, while collectively spending $255.3 million on digital and TV advertising in 2021 to compete with established car manufacturers and dealerships.
Top B2B Mergers and Acquisitions from Q3
In Q3, major B2B mergers and acquisitions—including AstraZeneca's $39 billion purchase of Alexion Pharmaceuticals to enhance mRNA and rare disease research, and Salesforce's $27.7 billion acquisition of Slack to strengthen workplace collaboration against Microsoft—totaled about $1.8 trillion in U.S. deals, with significant increases in advertising spend post-acquisition, such as Alexion's ad budget growing over tenfold and Slack expanding its television advertising presence.
Win Ad Revenue with Winmo Media Sales Leads
Winmo is a comprehensive, researcher-verified sales intelligence platform that helps advertising professionals quickly find and connect with over 230,000 verified media buying and ad sales decision-makers across brands and agencies managing $100 billion in ad spend, providing real-time media buying insights, direct contact information, and predictive sales alerts to streamline prospecting and close deals faster.
Prospect Now: 4 New Business Opportunities - Winmo
The WinmoEdge report for early 2019 highlights four new business opportunities, including Walgreens Boots Alliance's appointment of Vineet Mehra as global CMO, signaling potential adtech sales growth amid the company's strong earnings and strategic leadership changes.
CMO Breakups: 5 Brands You Should Start Wooing For New Business
The article highlights five major brands, including Facebook and Lands’ End, that have recently experienced CMO departures, signaling upcoming agency roster changes and presenting timely opportunities for agencies to pursue new business by engaging with these brands' marketing teams before new CMOs are appointed.