Programmatic Advertising in 2023: Who's Buying and Why It Matters
In 2023, despite an overall 8% decline in national digital ad spending to $46 billion and a 13% drop in programmatic ad spend—most notably a 31% decrease in the technology sector—programmatic advertising still dominated 74% ($35 billion) of digital spend, while direct ad spending grew 7% to nearly $12 billion, driven by sectors like tech, home furnishings, and professional services, highlighting brands' strategic shifts amid economic caution.
Brands are consistently leaning into ad technology to deliver precise, tailored ads to their target audience. But who’s buying programmatically, and why does it matter? MediaRadar’s latest analysis uncovers key trends and insights into the realm of programmatic advertising.
The Rise and Decline of Digital Advertising
2022 was a remarkable year for digital advertisers. Post-COVID restrictions generated an advertising boom, with brands scrambling to capture pent-up consumer demand. As restrictions lifted and the world took steps towards normalcy, digital ad spending skyrocketed.
However, by 2023, the scene changed. Global economic concerns have ushered in an air of caution. Brands are now more deliberate with their ad dollars, meticulously choosing where to place them.
In a landscape where cautious spending prevails, one thing remains consistent: programmatic ad buying continues to dominate the digital space.
Digital Ad Trends: The Numbers
MediaRadar’s analysis of ad spending from national digital media outlets shows that by Q3 2023, national digital advertising was at $46 billion. Despite this impressive number, digital spending noted an 8% year-over-year (YoY) decline from 2022.
This downturn is predominantly due to a slump in programmatic spending, which decreased by 13% YoY. Industries such as technology observed a significant decline in programmatic ad spend by 31% YoY, settling at $3.8 billion.
However, programmatic ad investments still commanded a large share, with 74% ($35 billion) of digital spend through Q3 2023 allocated to programmatic channels.
On the other hand, direct ad spend has shown growth. Up 7% YoY, direct ad expenditures reached nearly $12 billion. Leading this uptrend are sectors like tech (increasing 7% YoY to $1.8 billion) and home furnishings, which saw a 19% YoY increase, amounting to $924 million. Professional services also increased their direct ad investments by 6% YoY, bringing their total to $763 million.
Top Programmatic Advertisers in 2023
By the end of Q3 2023, 136,000 companies were buying programmatic ads for about 208,000 brands or product lines. This represents 83% of the nearly 165,000 companies that opted for digital advertising during this period.
Several top companies, including industry giants like Amazon.com, Comcast, Hyundai, and Mondelez, dedicated 80% or more of their budgets to programmatic spending, emphasizing its significance in today’s ad landscape. Among advertising categories, eleven out of 27 allocated more than $1 billion solely for programmatic advertising. Leading this list are media & entertainment and retail advertisers, with over 80% of their digital ad dollars flowing programmatically. Apparel, food, and beauty are also categories to target for ad tech sales opportunities.
However, there are outliers. The home furnishings category, including furniture, maintenance items, and outdoor products, leaned less into programmatic channels, placing less than 60% of their digital ads through ad tech.
Looking ahead, several brands, such as Aflac, H&M, and Old Spice, seem poised to bolster their programmatic ad spending, with predicted RFPs slated for Q4.
The Future of Programmatic Advertising
The world of programmatic advertising is dynamic and shaped by myriad external factors. While there has been a YoY decrease, the resilience of ad tech remains undeniable. Companies are still betting big on programmatic, signaling its enduring relevance in the ever-evolving advertising ecosystem.
For advertisers and ad sales professionals keen on staying ahead, harnessing advertising intelligence is paramount. Ad sales professionals leveraging real-time insights and data can make informed decisions on how to target key brands for success, ensuring their sales efforts yield optimal results.
Why Does It All Matter?
MediaRadar’s analysis highlights that while programmatic advertising has seen a slight decline in 2023, it still makes up the vast majority of digital ad investments. Advertisers across industries continue to lean heavily into ad tech to reach their target audiences.
For ad sales professionals, these insights indicate that programmatic channels remain crucial for prospecting new business. Focus sales outreach on categories investing heavily in ad tech like retail, media, entertainment, and apparel brands. Use real-time data to identify brands increasing their programmatic budgets.
For publishers, direct ad sales present an area of growth to capitalize on. Allocate resources to building direct relationships with advertisers in home furnishings, tech, and professional services. Develop tailored offerings to attract these brands investing more in direct channels.
The programmatic landscape will continue to evolve rapidly. By leveraging timely advertising intelligence and data, ad sellers and publishers alike can adjust strategies to drive revenue and stay ahead in 2024’s digital advertising arena.
Related
12 Ads ‘til New Year: 10 Biggest Programmatic Advertisers
In 2020, amid the pandemic-driven shift to flexible and targeted marketing, the top ten programmatic advertisers collectively spent $153 million, with Lending Tree leading at $23 million by addressing financial struggles, followed by Wix's Editor X platform at $18 million, and GEICO Insurance at $16 million capitalizing on increased insurance plan switching.
Q4 2023 12 for ‘24 - Beauty
In 2023, the beauty sector saw a 3% year-over-year decline in ad spend totaling over $5.2 billion across 5,200 companies and 11,600 brands, with TV still dominating at 34% of spend despite a 10% drop, while online video and native ads surged by 35% and 41% respectively, driven by increased investments in deodorant (up 72%), skincare, and hair care, alongside notable spending spikes from companies like P&G, and a mixed performance with declines in oral hygiene and bath & shower advertising, as MediaRadar highlights 12 key beauty advertisers poised for growth in 2024.
2023 Advertising Prediction: Retail Advertisers Continue Ramping Up Spend
In 2022, despite economic challenges like inflation and recession fears, U.S. retail advertisers significantly increased their spending—totaling $11.1 billion through Q3 with a 13% year-over-year rise—particularly in categories such as general retail, food and drug, apparel, home furnishings, and online department stores, signaling strong confidence in consumer demand heading into 2023.
4 Surprising Brands That Aren’t Buying Programmatic Ads in 2021
In 2021, despite increasing programmatic ad spending overall driven by privacy-driven changes like Apple's ATT and Google's cookie alternatives, many top advertisers are shifting their strategies, with only 8 of the top 100 programmatic buyers from 2020 returning in 2021, reflecting a 38% year-over-year increase in spend but notable brand departures from programmatic advertising.
MediaRadar | Publishers
MediaRadar provides publishers with comprehensive advertising intelligence solutions—including market, competitive, and commercial insights—to enhance media sales through strategic planning, targeted prospecting, and data-driven pitches, supported by tools for sales management, account executives, revenue operations, research, and business development, while offering detailed reports like the MediaWatch® Investment Blueprint 2025 that analyze advertiser spending across digital, out-of-home, paid social, print, radio, linear TV, OTT, and streaming TV to help clients stay competitive and maximize revenue.
MediaRadar’s Recession Ready Weekly Advertising Overview: Kids & Pets advertisers increase ad spend
During the week of December 19, 2022, MediaRadar observed significant week-over-week increases in advertising spend, including over 10% growth in Services (notably medical, dental, and health/fitness), a 1000%+ surge in Pet advertising driven by pet food and supplies reaching $1.5–$2 million, a similar 1000%+ increase in Athletics ads focused on fitness equipment and golf clubs totaling $3.5–$4 million, and a 20% rise in Baby/Children ads (mainly toys and games) investing $5–$7.5 million, reflecting seasonal and New Year’s resolution marketing trends.